ACT 2
Act two opens in a yarn factory in Kilcar. Patrick Hegarty, one of Matthew’s workmates, is celebrating an improvement in trade (Things Are Looking Better Now).
Hearing Patrick and co-worker Bridget O’Donnell talking about matchmaking, Matthew asks Patrick about how he met his wife, and how their marriage had been arranged (The Best Decision We Never Made).
Realising that it is unlikely that his parents and Nuala’s parents will ever meet, and therefore will not ever arrange his marriage to Nuala, Matthew must arrange it himself.
He also reveals that he is infatuated with Nuala (She Is Always On My Mind).
Meanwhile, back in London, George Vaughan Hart again meets with Henry Francis Conyngham. They come up with another plan, this time to repeal the Irish Stills Fine Bill,
which had been enacted for the purpose of suppressing the illicit distillation of spirits in Ireland, with consequences for their constituents, and themselves (I Have A Plan - Reprise).
A few days later, at Glen Head, Matthew notices a house fire on Arranmore, and reaffirms that he must arrange his marriage to Nuala (She Is Always On My Mind - Reprise).
At the next Fair Day in Dungloe, Matthew anxiously awaits Nuala’s arrival. She has been delayed after attending a mass on Arranmore,
and also because of fog on the journey from Arranmore. Matthew asks Nuala if they could be married (I Was Meant To Be With You), and Nuala says yes, but she will need to get permission from her parents.
As they might not see each other until the next Fair Day in a month’s time, Matthew is concerned that he will not know their fate until then.
Nuala suggests that if permission is granted, she will light a bonfire on one of the highest peaks on Arranmore Island,
and he will be able to see the bonfire from Glen Head, near his home. They arrange a time of just after dusk the following evening (When The Sun In The Sky Meets The Sea).
That evening, Nuala heads to Arranmore, but there is a thick fog at the port in Burtonport, and she cannot travel to the island.
She is offered a ride to her sister's house, where her parents are now staying. The fog could last for days,
so Nuala vows that she will not let this setback prevent her from getting permission to marry from her parents, and then letting Matthew know the answer (I Will Find A Way).
The following day, in a yarn factory in Kilcar, Patrick reassures Matthew that despite the fog he may still be able to see the island from Glen Head.
Matthew arrives at the signal tower as dusk approaches, only to find the head covered in low lying cloud, and visibility down to a few yards.
He wonders how he will know if the bonfire is lit on Arranmore (How Will I Know?).
Matthew resigns himself to the fact that he will not know the answer on that day. As he does, out of the fog, Nuala, having obtained permission,
joins him at the signal tower (I’ll Be Here - Reprise).